Math paradoxes

Glossary / Normal distribution

Glossary · normal distribution

Why does chance draw the same bell every time?

A ball falls through rows of pegs and bounces left or right off each one, as if tossing a coin. Nobody can say where this particular ball will land. Yet a thousand balls build the same bell-shaped pile every time. That bell is called the normal distribution, and it turns up wherever many small random pushes add up.

In plain wordspictures, analogies, small numbers

“In plain words” is hidden on all puzzles.

The Galton board paradox

The board of pegs was invented by the English scientist Francis Galton in the 19th century. This one has 12 rows of pegs and 13 bins. Drop one ball and try to guess where it will land. Then drop a thousand.

Balls in the bins0
In the three middle bins–

Chaos in the small, order in the large

A single ball is unpredictable, while a thousand balls are wonderfully predictable. A ball in an end bin would have to bounce the same way 12 times in a row, and that happens very rarely. But countless different paths lead to the middle: a little left, a little right, and the bounces cancel each other out. So the middle is always full and the edges are almost empty.

Rigoroustables, charts, formulas

“Rigorous” is hidden on all puzzles.

Two numbers describe the whole bell

Any normal distribution is fully set by two numbers. The mean μ says where the top of the bell is. The standard deviation σ says how wide it is: how far values usually stray from the mean. Change μ and the bell moves. Change σ and it becomes wider and lower, or narrower and taller. The shape is always the same.

The 68–95–99.7 rule

For any bell, about 68% of values lie within ±1 σ of the mean, 95% within ±2 σ, and 99.7% within ±3 σ. Let's check it on height. The numbers are made up for the example: say adult men somewhere have a mean height of 176 cm and σ = 7 cm. Below are 10,000 random people.

Heights in this range–
Inside · simulation–
Inside · formula–

Try 1, 2 and 3. About 3 people in 1,000 fall outside ±3 σ: here that means shorter than 155 cm or taller than 197 cm.

When to trust the bell, and when not to

The bell appears when a result is the sum of many small independent pushes, none of which dominates. When these conditions break, the bell lies, most often in the tails: very large values happen far more often than it promises.

  • Measurement errorsTrust it. A shaking hand, dust, temperature: many small causes add up, and the errors form a bell.
  • The average of a large sampleTrust it. Even when individual values follow any odd distribution, their average wobbles almost like a bell.
  • Height within one sexMostly trust it: genes and nutrition make many small contributions. But in the far tails illness plays a part, and there the bell is inaccurate.
  • IncomesDon't trust it. Incomes multiply rather than add: raises in percent, interest on interest. The distribution comes out skewed, with a long tail to the right, and the mean runs away from the median. There is a separate glossary article on that, about the median and the mean.
  • WealthEven less. The richest people own millions of times more than a typical person. A person a million times taller than typical would stand 1,760 kilometres tall.
  • When everyone pushes togetherDon't trust it. In a market panic everyone sells at once, the pushes stop being independent, and big crashes happen far more often than a bell would allow.
Deepergeneralisations, theory, history

“Deeper” is hidden on all puzzles.

Counting paths

P(bin k) = C(12, k) / 2¹²  ·  C(12, 6) = 924,  C(12, 0) = 1,  2¹² = 4096

Each ball passes 12 pegs, and each of the 4,096 possible paths is equally likely. The bin depends only on the number of bounces to the right, k. One path leads to an end bin, 924 lead to the middle one. That gives the shape: the middle bin collects 924/4096 ≈ 22.6% of the balls, while each end bin gets just 1/4096, about one ball in four thousand. This is the binomial distribution.

The board against the formula

The bars are the shares of the balls you dropped on the board above. The dots are the binomial distribution, the exact path count. The line is the normal curve with μ = 6 and σ = √3 ≈ 1.73 bins. The more balls, the closer the bars get to the dots, and the dots already sit almost on the curve.

balls on the boardbinomialnormal curve

Middle bin · board–
· binomial22.6%
· curve height23.0%

Anything added up many times becomes a bell

A bounce on the board is a coin. But the coin is not essential. A die is completely flat: each face 1/6, no bell at all. Add up the scores of several dice and the bell appears by itself: two dice give a triangle, three already look like a bell. This is the idea of the central limit theorem: the sum of many independent, identically distributed quantities with any finite spread tends to a normal distribution. Abraham de Moivre noticed it for coins as early as 1733.

Mean of the sums · simulation and formula 3.5 n–
σ of the sums · simulation and formula √(35 n / 12)–

20,000 throws for each n. The line is the normal curve with the same mean and σ.

The formula of the bell

f(x) = 1 / (σ √(2π)) · e−(x − μ)² / (2σ²)

The whole shape lives in e−z²/2, where z = (x − μ) / σ is the distance from the mean measured in σ. At 1 σ the curve is 61% of its peak height, at 2 σ 13.5%, at 3 σ only 1.1%. The square in the exponent makes the tails incredibly thin: the chance of landing more than 10 σ above the mean is less than one in 10²³. The factor 1 / (σ √(2π)) only makes the area under the curve equal 1. These thin tails are the main difference between the bell and incomes or markets, where far-off values happen incomparably more often.

Where it shows up

Other terms